All over $6 million in Facebook’s Brazilian bank account has been frozen on court order in a further dispute about encrypted data involving local police authorities and Facebook-owned messaging app WhatsApp, in accordance to the regional Globo G1 news services.

The dispute pertains to WhatsApp messages that Brazilian federal police want accessibility to to progress an worldwide medicine investigation, ongoing since January, Reuters reports.

WhatsApp and its guardian corporation Facebook have earlier maintained they do not shop nor have accessibility to the metadata and message data Brazilian police are requesting. WhatsApp completed a rollout of conclusion-to-conclusion encryption across its services this April — firmly locking it out from the ability to decrypt users’ messages, and cementing its fingers-off stance on users’ content.

There have been a number of such stand offs in excess of encrypted data in between WhatsApp and Brazilian police, with a court docket buying a 48 several hours block on the services very last December in a equivalent circumstance, despite the fact that a further decide subsequently lifted that block early.

Back in March Facebook’s VP in Latin American was also arrested in relationship with the investigation. Then in May a further regional court docket purchased a seventy two hour block on WhatsApp — which was also subsequently lifted early. It appears like regional courts are now pursuing a economical penalty selection to penalize the corporation extra than its users.

The $19.5 million reais of frozen Facebook cash are equal to WhatsApp’s gathered fines for non-compliance in the circumstance, in accordance to G1. WhatsApp does not have any bank accounts in the nation — that’s why Facebook remaining qualified.

We’ve achieved out to Facebook and WhatsApp for remark about the hottest enhancement and will update this submit with any reaction.

WhatsApp CEO and co-founder Jan Koum has earlier stated the corporation has no intention of “compromising the safety of our billion users close to the world” by weakening its safety units in purchase to be equipped to comply with police authority requests for data.

Koum’s stance mirrors a position taken by Apple previously this calendar year, in a circumstance involving the FBI seeking accessibility to a locked Iphone which had been used by a terrorist. In that instance the FBI finally paid a 3rd-bash corporation to gain accessibility to the system, after in the beginning attempting a legal route to try to pressure Apple to weaken its very own safety units.

Governments and law enforcement organizations in numerous countries have been stepping up their rhetoric against technological know-how companies’ use of conclusion-to-conclusion encryption in the latest occasions — arguing it is unacceptable for a strategy of conversation to exist that can’t be accessed by condition agents in extremis.

Nevertheless the counter argument, as Koum has observed, is that any deliberate weakening of security units to afford to pay for accessibility to precise authorities also opens the door to exploit by hackers — therefore posing a safety possibility to all users of a service.